Teen Book Reviews

Click here to read reviews by PPLD’s Review Crew - book reviews by teens, for teens.

A Court of Thorns and Roses Book Jacket
Maas, Sarah J.
4 stars = Really Good
Review:

When I had initially read this book I had given it five stars, but now that I look back, it definitely got knocked down to a four.
Feyre, a human, ends up killing a wolf and is taken away by a fae for retribution. This book was supposedly a Beauty and the Beast retelling, but it did not seem like it, at all. I did like the concept of the book, but some of the characters are so unlikeable I was confused with the motives behind their actions. That kind of made it hard to enjoy some of the plotlines. This book was a lot of world building, which I enjoyed, but it does not pick up until closer to the end. I did overall like this book and I think it is worth picking up.

Reviewer's Name: Rowan Grade 11
The Naturals Book Jacket
Barnes, Jennifer Lynn
4 stars = Really Good
Review:

I really liked the concept behind this book—it felt unique and pulled me into a genre I don’t usually read. The story follows 17-year-old Cassie Hobbes, who gets recruited into a special FBI program made up of gifted teens, each with their own talents that help solve crimes.
I thought this was a good strong introduction to the series and the characters. I really liked the team dynamic and how each character brought something different to the table. Their interactions were interesting to read and made reading more enjoyable.
That said, there were moments when the writing felt a little dramatic and some plot points came together too neatly, like everything just worked out a little too perfectly. It made certain scenes feel less believable, even though the overall story was still really engaging.
I did however enjoy the twists. Even when I had some suspicions, I was still surprised, and those moments definitely added to the excitement. I'm curious to see how the story and characters develop in the next books.

Reviewer's Name: Rowan, Grade 11
Yaqui Delgado quiere darte una paliza Book Jacket
Medina, Meg
4 stars = Really Good
Review:

I read this book's Spanish translation, something I don't often do because many translations are disorienting from bad word choice and tonal shift. However, I really enjoyed this particular translation! It was poetic and had good flow. It's hard to find good books in Spanish just because of their relative scarcity, so I'm glad that PPLD has this one, and I hope they can continue to increase their collection of books in other languages.
This book is a coming of age story about Piedad "Piddy" Sanchez, a 16 year old girl in New York who switches high schools after she and her mom move away from their old apartment. At her new school, she is severely bullied by Yaqui Delgado, a classmate who lives in a bad neighborhood and thinks Piddy is stuck up and "a fox". During this time, she must deal with her changing body, growing apart from an old friend, getting along with her mother, and other problems.
My favorite part of this book was Piddy herself. She wasn't a perfect protagonist who always made the perfect, most logical choice. She also wasn't a character who was unreasonable simply for dramatic effect. She felt like a real person, and her motivations, struggles, and choices always made sense for her character. I admired her resilience and values. Despite touching on themes such as sexism and poverty, the book doesn't go as incredibly in depth on them as the themes of abuse, family, and hope. However, it makes sense because this book is, at the forefront, a story about Piddy and what she discovers about herself in the face of challenge.
I recommend this book to anyone looking for a classic coming-of-age story with an interesting, relatable protagonist, and I especially recommend the Spanish translation for anyone struggling to find captivating stories in Spanish.

Reviewer's Name: Isabel
Sunrise on the Reaping book jacket
Collins, Suzanne
5 stars = Bohemian Rhapsody Awesome!
Review:

I am in shock from reading this book. So many questions from both the original trilogy and The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes were answered. I saw an analogy, where the original trilogy are the middle pieces of a puzzle, The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes is the corners and Sunrise on the Reaping is the edges. I could not agree more, the way they are all perfectly balanced on each other and with Sunrise on the Reaping, Collins paints a whole new picture that really makes you question the whole series.

This book follows Haymitch Abernathy and his story with the 50th Hunger Games. The writing style changes and reflects with each character in the different books, being able to see Haymitch's thoughts and the things that happen which gives a better insight into why he acted in the original trilogy. I loved this book and it is five stars without a doubt.

Reviewer Grade: 11

Reviewer's Name: Rowan
Kingdom of Ash Book Jacket
Maas, Sarah J.
4 stars = Really Good
Review:

As the final book in the series, Throne of Glass, I am in shock of how far the series has progressed. Kingdom of Ash is a spectacular ending to a series that is very well written. At almost 1000 pages long, Kingdom of Ash is truly an ending worthy of the story. Everything has come back in a full circle movement that leaves the reader guessing what will happen next. Aelin Galathynius, her cadre, and her allies at last face off against the enemy as the last way to protect her home kingdom of Terrasen. There are so many different plotlines that connect back to eachother and show how Maas was a mastermind with every single moment in all 8 books. While I loved all the moments in the book, it was a very long book and I believe it did draw out to a point where I just wanted to finish the book.

Reviewer's Name: Rowan Grade 11
Sunrise on the Reaping Book Jacket
Collins, Suzann
5 stars = Bohemian Rhapsody Awesome!
Review:

I am in shock from reading this book. So many questions from both the original triology and The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes were answered. I saw an analogy, where the original trilogy are the middle pieces of a puzzle, The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes is the corners and Sunrise on the Reaping is the edges. I could not agree more, the way they are all perfectly balanced on eachother and with Sunrise on the Reaping, Collins paints a whole new picture that really makes you question the whole series.
This book follows Haymitch Abernathy and his story with the 50th Hunger Games. The writing style changes and reflects with each character in the different books, being able to see Haymitch's thoughts and the things that happen which gives a better insight into why he acted in the original trilogy. I loved this book and is five starts without a doubt.

Reviewer's Name: Rowan Grade 11
Cover of the book Frankenstein, or, the Modern Prometheus
Shelly, Mary
4 stars = Really Good
Review:

I really enjoyed reading this book! Mary Shelley's 'Frankenstein' is a classic novel that everyone knows. It's a tale about Victor Frankenstein, a scientist, and how he creates life. Except it's made from body parts. What I liked about reading this is that this is the original. Young readers don't really know about all the other complex parts of the story. It was so interesting to read and learn about a narrative I never knew before. More on the plot, it's about how Victor creates a creature and then the seemingly endless and terrifying consequences.
However, this book is incredibly hard to read. The old way it's written makes it easier to get lost or not completely understand what happened. There's a lot of words I had to look up, but the context also helps decipher it. One of my favorite parts of the book is the building suspense. Ultimately, I think this book has so much beauty, because of all the emotions I had while reading it and the message it carries about human nature.

Reviewer's Name: Max
Defy the Night
Kemmerer, Brigid
4 stars = Really Good
Review:

The kingdom of Kandala is suffering from a rapidly spreading illness that has only one known cure: an elixer made from Moonflower Petals that only grow in very specific conditions. The cure is hoarded by the rich, and too expensive for the poor. Defy the Night follows both the undercover thief Tessa Cade, who steals the elixir from the elite and redistributes to the poor, and the feared Prince Corrick, who works to keep his sickly older brother in power.
When Tessa and Corrick's lives unexpectedly cross, their hatred turns into a tolerated partnership, which begins to spark into something more. Tessa and Corrick struggle to keep their feelings in check as they work to keep their kingdom from falling to constant rebellions and the plague.

Defy the Night was a very fast paced read, with political intrigue and betrayals, romance, forming friendships and plenty of action to satisfy almost all aspects of a fantasy novel. I thought all the characters were very well thought out, even the side characters who work with/against Tessa and Corrick. I also felt that the romance was very well balanced with the plot. It didn't overshadow the plot but rather made the plot more dense, and also helped contribute to the character development. I would recommend!

Reviewer's Name: Reagan
Grenade
Gratz, Alan
5 stars = Bohemian Rhapsody Awesome!
Review:

Hideki is living in Okinawa Japan when America is invading. All he knows is that they are monsters who will try to kill him and his family. All he has is two grenades and the orders to use one on the Americans and the other on himself. Ray is part of the American army, and he has to attack the island of Okinawa on D-day. He is told to try to save the citizens but how easy could that be when she is in the middle of a war?

Grenade by award winning author Alan Gratz is a great look into the grim truths of war. It is an example of how fear and conflict can create a monster of a person. This novel is a historical fiction gem and has amazing philosophical undertones with well thought of characters and a carefully crafted story. This is an amazing book, and a lot of people would enjoy reading it.

Reviewer's Name: Drake
Awards:
Ground Zero
Gratz, Alan
5 stars = Bohemian Rhapsody Awesome!
Review:

Brandon and Reshmina have both been affected by the attacks on 9/11. He was in the north tower elevator when the first one hit. She was born in Afghanistan faced with constant war, now the Americans were inside her country too. Both of them have been hurt by the events on 9/11 but when the bigger picture will eventually arise, they will be tested to think, is revenge the right way to go?

Ground Zero by award winning author Alan Gratz is a masterwork in historical fiction. It has extensive details into the tragedy of 9/11 and the hardship during the war in Afghanistan. It has well-built characters with unique ideas and traits. Ground Zero can get you to reflect on war and revenge and is an amazing book for an assortment of people.

Reviewer's Name: Drake
Prisoner B-3087
Gratz, Alan
5 stars = Bohemian Rhapsody Awesome!
Review:

The nazi’s are gaining power and are starting their travel through Europe, starting with Poland. In the city of Krakow, Yanek will be plunged into the terrible truths of World War 2 as it unfolds around him. Houses are raided as the nazi party are looking for supplies and Jews are beaten. Yanek will have to persevere through perilous feats to stay alive, he will be mentally challenged in grit and his will to live.

Prisoner B-3087 by award-winning author Alan Gratz is a bone-chilling jewel with a deep look into the past. It is incredibly immersive and intense with great scenes throughout. The book is a great show of history and human brutality and a masterwork in historical fiction. I believe this is an amazing book for a variety of individuals and many people should read it.

Reviewer's Name: Drake
Awards:
The Waves
Woolf, Virginia
3 stars = Pretty Good
Review:

Written in the “stream of consciousness” style, this book is very interesting, but honestly hard to read. There are 6 characters who we follow. Starting when they’re pre-schooler age, to their deaths. Each character has definitive characteristics. I believe each character is supposed to be relatable to in some way, as many of them battle with insecurities, self-comparisons, passions, depression, etc. The writing itself is very good, but it just wasn’t my favorite.

Reviewer's Name: Edda
Genres:
Wuthering Heights
Brontë, Emily
4 stars = Really Good
Review:

Wuthering Heights by Emily Brontë is a masterpiece! I definitely see why it is such a well known novel. However, it is a Victorian gothic novel, so it does explore uncomfortable themes such as incest and abuse. However, it doesn’t delve into them in a way that’s triggering or uncomfortable. This novel focuses on the Earnshaws, a wealthy family that owns the manor Wuthering Heights. While the family of four once lived happily, one night their father returns home with a new child named Heathcliff. A darker-skinned child from unknown origins. As the child adapts to his new environment, facing abuse and belittlement, he begins to slowly take over the manor. This story is super interesting if you’re interested in dramatic stories! I’d definitely recommend, just be wary of any uncomfortable themes. :)

Reviewer's Name: Edda
Genres:
Invisible Man
Ellison, Ralph
4 stars = Really Good
Review:

I recently had to read this novel for a class, and I have to say it is very good! While it explores complicated themes such as visibility, African-American movements/social standing, and life in early 1900’s America, it communicates the hardships and intricacies extremely well. The narrator, a black man in the early 1930’s-1940’s, loses his memory of his early life, including his family and even name. He travels through America; experiencing, learning, and exploring what his new life has to offer. Every experience is different, yet still very interesting, which made it feel like I was almost reading separate stories! Yet, it didn’t feel choppy or fragmented in the least. So, I’d highly recommend! I’ve never read any other book like this, and it definitely taught me a lot.

Reviewer's Name: Edda
Tower of Dawn
Maas, Sarah J.
4 stars = Really Good
Review:

Tower of Dawn is the sixth book in the Throne of Glass series and focuses on Chaol Westfall and his journey to heal his legs and spine. This book takes a very different perspective from the previous books and introduces us into more of the political landscape from across the sea, which offers a fresh perspective on the series.

At the start, Chaol was one of my least favorite characters, but this book shows him in a more vulnerable and complex light that is makes him seem more relatable to the reader. His personal struggles add depth to his characters and makes me appreciate why Maas decided to have a book focused on him.

I chose to tandem read this book with Empire of Storms and I would highly recommend to put in the effort to tandem read. Since both books happen simultaneously, the way how timelines intertwine creates for a really complicated and beautifully written piece. The only reason it is rated 4 stars is because I do believe it drags on for a little bit, but it leads up to Kingdom of Ash perfectly.

Reviewer's Name: Rowan
Genres:
Empire of Storms
Maas, Sarah J.
5 stars = Bohemian Rhapsody Awesome!
Review:

The fifth book in Throne of Glass, Empire of Storms, is a masterfully written book that builds up for an amazing edning to the series. The buildup is intense, and Sarah J. Maas has been creating complicated and interwoven plotlines since the beginning.

I chose to tandem read Empire of Storms alongside Tower of Dawn, the sixth book, which required dedication but was absolutely worth it. Experiencing both stories added depth to the overall narrative and enhanced my appreciation for the two books and how aligned they were.

In this book, Aelin Galathynius must rally allies for the looming war, and the stakes have never been higher. Maas has an incredible ability to immerse readers into her books. Her world-building is impeccable, and this book highlights how carefully she has been plotting this journey from the very start and when everything finally clicks into place, it leaves me in awe of her ability to craft such an intricate and amazing story.

Without a doubt, Empire of Storms is a strong contender for my favorite book in the series.

Reviewer's Name: Rowan
Genres:
Mistborn: The Final Empire
Sanderson, Brandon
5 stars = Bohemian Rhapsody Awesome!
Review:

Rebellion in this world is impossible, the king is immortal, and the people are weak, but Kelsier is determined to make a change. Kelsier has a wild plan, Vin a street urchin, gets wound up in this plan. She realizes that this goes deeper than she thought, and that there is always another secret.

This is one of the first books by Brandon Sanderson I've read and it's magnificent. This fantasy book is one of the best I've read, with twists and turns in every chapter. The characters feel real because of their bonds with each other. This is definitely a book that explores relationships, magic, and rebellion.

Reviewer's Name: Olivia
Genres:
As Good as Dead
Jackson, Holly
4 stars = Really Good
Review:

After the last investigation Pip is haunted by what events that transpired. She can't seem to escape the last investigation and with the death threats becoming more severe, she is left to solve this case. Pip thinks that this case will solve her, but this time the stakes are higher, and if she doesn't find out who this is she will disappear.

I think this book was truly amazing, Holly Jackson did a fantastic job explaining the effects of the last book (Good Girl, Bad Blood). The ending was dark and twisted. This is a great book for mystery lovers.

Reviewer's Name: Olivia
The Wingfeather Saga: On the Edge of the Dark Sea of Darkness
Peterson, Andrew
3 stars = Pretty Good
Review:

On the Edge of the Dark Sea of Darkness follows three siblings, Janner, Tink, and Leeli Igiby, as well as their trusty dog Nugget, as they live under the rule of Fangs of Dang, who oppress their peaceful village. The kids have always tried to stay on the Fangs' good side, but a series of events leads to the three kids' actions directly working against the Fangs of Dang, and now they must work with some new friends to keep their family together and safe.

If you enjoy world building, this book is for you. The author includes many in depth details about the new world, even if some details feel unnecessary. The author explains the significance of various animals, cultures, songs, and recipes that are completely unique to this world.

I felt some parts of this book, particularly the beginning, were slow as the author built the Igiby's world. The adventure doesn't really begin until a little before half way through the book. However, after finishing the rest of the series, the world building is necessary as this book leads into a 5 star series!

Reviewer's Name: Reagan
Genres:
Sunrise on the Reaping
Collins, Suzanne
5 stars = Bohemian Rhapsody Awesome!
Review:

Sunrise on the Reaping follows Haymitch Abernathy and his experience in the Hunger Games, a reality TV show where kids must fight to the death. However, this specific round of Hunger Games has a special twist from the traditional Hunger Games. Due to this Hunger Games being the 50th annual Hunger Games, (also known as the second "Quarter Quell"), Haymitch must face twice as many opponents in his battle of survival.

I finished this book in two days! Even though Sunrise on the Reaping is a prequel and I already knew the outcome, Suzanne Collins still found ways to make the book compelling and interesting, with twists and turns that made this story completely unique. The story was not as predictable as I assumed it to be, which made for a very fun read!

Despite Sunrise on the Reaping being part of the overall Hunger Games series, you could read it as a stand alone without the other books in the series and still enjoy it. There are no dull moments, even from the very first page Collins is able to draw the reader into the world and keep the reader there until the very last page.

Reviewer's Name: Reagan
Projekt 1065
Gratz, Alan
5 stars = Bohemian Rhapsody Awesome!
Review:

November 9th, 1938 was nicknamed the night of broken glass, and it was on this day that Michael’s eyes were opened to the horror that was the nazi’s. Shops were destroyed, Jews were beaten, killed, and arrested. Soon Michael discovers that his parents, the ambassadors for the Irish embassy in Berlin, are secretly collecting information for the allies against Germany. With his photographic memory and determination to bring justice to a Hitler ruled Germany, Michael will help with the cause however can even if it means becoming the most convincing nazi youth. He will uncover secrets that the nazi’s are hiding, that only he can prevent.

Projekt 1065 by award winning author Alan Gratz is a masterpiece in writing giving an accurate representation of World War 2. He shows the terrible truths of the time and the way the citizens were brainwashed in a captivating plot and immersive story. With perfect descriptions and thrilling plot twists you will be interested in the book the entire way through. This book is an example of an amazing historical fiction book, and I believe that many people will enjoy this novel.

Reviewer's Name: Drake
Son
Lowry, Lois
4 stars = Really Good
Review:

For those who want a story that is nothing short of enlightening, Lois Lowry’s “Son” is the book for you. The fourth and final book in the eye-opening “The Giver” series, the storylines of all the previous books are masterfully and artistically woven into a single thread. Claire, a Birthmother in her community, has her world turned upside down when her baby is taken from her. Now, she must embark on the journey of a lifetime to get him back — no matter what the price. In my humble opinion, this is one of the most fantastic books I have ever read. Being the last book in the series, it has the ability to cultivate an incredibly powerful and complex story that keeps readers heartstrings tied to the page. It’s got plot twists, evil and mysterious villains, amazing shows of strength, moments of joy, sadness, fear, and surprise, all while carrying one warm, loving message. If “Messenger” left you wanting for more, read “Son”. Trust me — it’s worth it.

Reviewer's Name: Dominic
Hatchet
Paulsen, Gary
5 stars = Bohemian Rhapsody Awesome!
Review:

I first read this book for a school assignment, but quickly fell in love with the outstanding novel Hatchet, by Gary Paulsen. Hatchet is a perfect survival book for nature lovers. Paulsen writes about a boy named Brain Robeson. With parents divorced, and a secret eating him from the inside, Brian’s life is in turmoil; However, his life changes the moment his plane crashes in the Canadian wilderness on a flight to his father’s house. Can Brain survive, or will he succumb to the sheer power of nature? Hatchet is a top notch book and will please any reader.

Reviewer's Name: Maverick
Darth Bane: Dynasty of Evil
Karpyshyn, Drew
4 stars = Really Good
Review:

Once already addicted to the previous two books of this series, the final book of the trio was a must have! Darth Bane: Dynasty of Evil keeps the readers on the edge of their seats! Bane has finally finished training his apprentice, Darth Zannah, in the ways of the Dark Side; However, she seems unwilling to take the title of master for her own. Bane must decide whether to wait longer for Zannah to overthrow him, or he much quickly choose a new apprentice. Which will he choose? Darth Bane, Dynasty of Evil is a perfect book for Star Wars fans, and is an epic ending to the Darth Bane Trilogy.

Reviewer's Name: Maverick
The Poppy War
Kuang, R. F.
5 stars = Bohemian Rhapsody Awesome!
Review:

What initially drew me into The Poppy War was all the great things I had heard about the book and it's author R.F. Kuang. Fang Runin, the female main character, was both enjoyable and relatable at many times as she fought for a spot in Sinegard, the country's most elite military academy, in hopes of getting away from an arranged marriage. The book spans over a few years and eventually deals with some very intense and dark themes throughout the book. Kuang does not shy away from any details and makes the book feel incredibly real and allows a deeper connection with the character's emotions.
The pace of the book really picks up towards the second half, and I was constantly surprised where the story went next. The Poppy War is also very heavily inspired by Chinese folklore, but Kuang adds her own touch to the story, making the book seem very unique. I really enjoyed this book and is a definite five star for me.

Reviewer's Name: Rowan
Genres:
Six of Crows
Bardugo, Leigh
5 stars = Bohemian Rhapsody Awesome!
Review:

Six of Crows is the adventure of six characters, each with different backgrounds and different goals, sharing the same mission: accomplish a high risk heist from one of the most fortified cities in the world. Each of the members of the group have significant enemies, each trying to stop the heist from happening. There is constant action, and the book is impossible to put down. The author incorporates the character's background to form bonds within the group; highlighting their strengths and weaknesses together. There is never a dull moment, and the story is filled with twists and turns that aren't expected, but enhance the novel's plot. I would recommend if anyone is trying to get out of a reading slump, or find a book that will have you invested from start to finish.

Reviewer's Name: Reagan
Genres:
Fablehaven Book Jacket
Brandon Mull
5 stars = Bohemian Rhapsody Awesome!
Review:

While the cover of Fablehaven, by Brandon Mull, may not be the most appealing, once the book is opened the reader is welcomed into a new, magical world, filled with sneaky satyrs, vain fairies, dangerous witches, and many more. Similarly, when Kendra and Seth are sent to their Grandfather's house for the summer, they don't expect to find an adventure waiting for them. A series of well-placed clues reveals a new, mysterious world to the two children, who must work to save it. Kendra and Seth make both friends and enemies in this preserve and learn the importance of following the rules, as well as risking them. Fablehaven was constantly surprising me, making it impossible to put down. The characters learn new things about what they are capable of accomplishing, which helps to inspire readers to reach outside of their comfort zone and discover what they can accomplish as well.

Reviewer's Name: Reagan Grade 10
Monstrous Devices Book Jacket
Damien Love
3 stars = Pretty Good
Review:

Before receiving what might have been the strangest gift ever, 12-year-old robot enthusiast Alex's life was already plagued enough with bullies and homework. But when he receives a toy robot from his enigmatic grandfather, along with a note that reads "This one is special," a sequence of supernatural events sets off around Alex, and right before things take a deadly turn, Alex's grandfather appears just in time to save his life...and pack him away in an impromptu snowy trip across Europe. As the two begin to unravel the mysteries behind the robot's magic, Alex finds himself becoming the main target of a group of mysterious assassins who follow his every move in the hopes of possessing his robot, and he is forced to battle villains of both human and robot form as he grapples with the immense, monstrous powers of his seemingly innocent toy.

Monstrous Devices is whimsical and unique, and although it is for middle-school aged children, the author is not afraid to add in some chilling, horror-adjacent plot points throughout the story (this novel literally begins with a murder scene...no more on that). While reading this book, I felt as if I was tagging along with Alex and his grandpa as they outwit the assassins; I could hear the robots the assassins used as weapons whizzing and whirring in their deadly attacks, and I could practically see the landscape this book is set in. The bits of history about robots and magic the author added in was also very intriguing, adding a mythical element to the story.

On the other hand, the ending of the book felt somewhat abrupt for me, and there were a lot of questions I had about the characters and the plot that were left unanswered. The lore behind the robot, and even Alex and his grandpa's own backstories, were a little hard to follow, and I ended up somewhat dissatisfied with the lack of conclusions the author gave. The characterizations of the assassins only left more questions, their motives were very unclear, and their eventual fate did not sit quite right with me. I do, however, know that there is a sequel to this book, and I hope that it will tie together some of the unresolved tensions.

In the end, even though it has its flaws, Monstrous Devices remains a magical and entertaining read that young readers will surely enjoy.

Reviewer's Name: Joyce
The Selection
Cass, Kiera
2 stars = Meh
Review:

In a distant future, the US has fallen after a devastating sequence of wars, and in its place rises a new nation by the name of Illéa. The country is led by a traditional monarchy, and society is divided into castes, with Ones (royals, elites) lying at the top of the pyramid and the lowly Eights (handicaps, homeless people, orphans etc.) at the bottom, ostracized and left to suffer at the hands of society. As a form of entertainment or tradition, when the King and Queen's male progeny comes of age, the government televises a show known as the Selection, which centers around thirty-five young girls of all different castes compete on national TV for the hand in marriage of the prince.

America Singer is a Five; she's an artist, a singer, like her last name suggests. For her, the prospect of entering in the Selection is nothing but a nightmare, as it threatens her budding relationship with Aspen, who is a caste below her. But after continuous persuasion and bribes from her mother, she decides to compete anyway and finds herself in the presence of Maxon, the young prince of the realm that thirty-four other girls are desperate to win the favor of. Slowly, America begins to fall for him, questioning her own desires.

I had first decided to pick up this book as I thought the concept of a futuristic caste system and a monarchy was very interesting. These types of books were also not ones that I would usually read, so I thought it would be nice to try something different for once. The Selection, for all of its simple and predictable plot structure, is a fairly easy and somewhat entertaining read; I finished the first book in two days! However, that's where the compliments stop. The book overuses too many common YA book tropes (enemies to lovers, love triangles) as well as basic, shallow character archetypes (feisty female main character, dreamy and sweet main love interest, bubbly best friend, superficial mean girls, etc). As mentioned before, the plot has barely any depth, and the mentions of rebel attacks on the royal family and the corrupted caste system seem like a low-quality effort to retain the dystopian aspect of the novel at best. Romance plays itself as the main focus of the novel, and while that is not necessarily bad, it does tend get extremely repetitive as much of the novel and even the whole series centers around America deciding whether or not she really loves Maxon (as well as vice versa). And as for the characters themselves, I found both America and Maxon insufferable and one-dimensional. The book lacks tension and is overall very plain.

I did manage to get through the entirety of the series; however, I do not recommend this book to anyone interested in novels with a blend of romance and dystopian/fantasy elements. There are books out there that execute these genres better than the Selection in my opinion.

Reviewer's Name: Joyce
Gearbreakers book jacket
Mikuta, Zoe Hana
4 stars = Really Good
Review:

Two queer Asian girls, on different sides of the war. When their paths collide, at first, they are each other's enemy until they both realize they're fighting for the same purpose, and with a tyrannical rule spreading they have to work together to rebel.

This book was amazing, definitely worth reading. This book was full of action, sci fi and romance. This is one of the most underrated books and deserves more recognition.

Reviewer's Name: Olivia